DIY home improvement projects can instill a sense of accomplishment and pride — and let’s face it, they often save us money, too. When “Today’s Homeowner” TV co-host Chelsea Lipford Wolf realized her dining table looked rough, she imagined that refinishing it would be the perfect affordable DIY fix.

Her plans were straightforward: She would sand off the tabletop’s paint, strip the stain, and apply a new wood stain for a refreshed, natural look. However, Chelsea soon realized something about DIY home improvement projects — they don’t always work out as expected. Keep reading to learn how Chelsea needed to troubleshoot when things didn’t go as planned during her dining table refinishing project. 



The First Steps of Refinishing a Dining Room Table

Chelsea started by sanding down the tabletop using an orbital sander. This step removed the top layer of paint and revealed the wood grain underneath. However, she quickly realized that simply sanding would not get down to the bare wood as she had hoped. Unfortunately, there were still patches of paint visible across the surface.

At this point, Chelsea determined she would need to use a paint stripper to remove the remaining paint entirely. She applied a thick coat of stripper across the entire tabletop and let it sit for the recommended time. The paint stripper helped loosen more of the paint, but it didn’t get down to the raw wood. After repeating the process several times with limited success, Chelsea decided to switch gears and try a different approach.


What To Do When Things Don’t Go As Planned

Chelsea did some research to understand why the paint stripper wasn’t working effectively. She learned that not all paint strippers work equally well on all paint and finishes. Her dining table’s original finish or color must have been especially durable.

During her research and trial and error process, she discovered some tips for improving paint stripper effectiveness:

  • Apply a thick and even coat of stripper across the entire surface. Uneven application can leave patches of finish behind.
  • Allow the stripper to sit for longer than the minimum recommended time. For particularly stubborn finishes, let it sit overnight and reapply as needed.
  • Use a plastic scraper to remove the softened paint and finish gently. Metal scrapers are too harsh and can damage the wood.
  • Mineral spirits can help remove any remaining sticky resin after scraping.

Armed with these tips, Chelsea was ready to try again.


Try Again

For her second attempt at stripping the table, Chelsea used a heavy-duty chemical stripper recommended for tough finishes. She applied a generous coat across the tabletop and let it sit overnight.

The next day, she began scraping off the gunky finish residue. She took her time, working in small sections and reapplying stripper as needed. After several hours, things were looking up — most of the tabletop was down to bare wood.

There were just a few trouble spots with the remaining paint. For these, Chelsea used a detail sander and mineral spirits to remove the last of the finish. This step allowed her to get down to smooth, raw wood across the surface.


Staining the Table

Now that Chelsea had removed the existing paint and finish, it was finally time to apply a new stain. She selected a gel stain that would allow her to control the color saturation and achieve a natural look.

Chelsea worked the gel stain into the wood using a foam applicator, wiping away any excess. She applied two coats, allowing each to dry before adding the next. 

The result was a beautifully refreshed dining table with dimension and warmth from the woodgrain shining through. The project was completed after she sealed the tabletop with a protective polyurethane coat.


So, Is Refinishing Furniture Worth the Effort?

Refinishing furniture yourself can be rewarding but requires patience and troubleshooting skills. As Chelsea learned, the existing paint or finish might not always strip as easily as expected.

However, with the right products, techniques, and elbow grease, you can successfully refinish even furniture with the most stubborn finishes. As a bonus, taking the DIY route rather than hiring a professional refinisher can save hundreds of dollars.


FAQs About Refinishing Furniture

What supplies do I need to refinish furniture?

Basic supplies include sandpaper, chemical paint stripper, plastic scraping tools, rags, stain, stain brushes or applicators, foam brushes, and polyurethane. You may also need mineral spirits for cleaning.


How long does it take to refinish a table?

It depends on the size of the table and how difficult the existing finish is to remove. It can take you anywhere from two days to a week to refinish a table.


Can I stain over an existing finish?

No, the stain will not penetrate a clear finish or paint properly. Always remove the existing coating first.


What safety precautions should I take?

Work in a well-ventilated area, wear gloves and eye protection, and be careful not to get chemical strippers on your skin or eyes. Follow all manufacturer safety directions.


What if there are damaged areas in the wood?

Fill small cracks, gouges, or holes with wood filler before sanding and applying a new stain. In my experience, you may need to use wood reinforcement patches for larger damaged areas.


Editorial Contributors
avatar for Amy DeYoung

Amy DeYoung

Contributor

Amy DeYoung has a passion for educating and motivating homeowners to improve their lives through home improvement projects and preventative measures. She is a content writer and editor specializing in pest control, moving, window, and lawn/gardening content for Today’s Homeowner. Amy utilizes her own experience within the pest control and real estate industry to educate readers. She studied business, communications, and writing at Arizona State University.

Learn More

photo of Lori Zaino

Lori Zaino

Lori Zaino is a freelance writer and editor based in Madrid, Spain. With nearly two decades of editorial experience, she’s written and edited for publications like Forbes, CNN, Insider, NBC, Newsweek, The Points Guy, The Infatuation, and many others. Having just completed her first home renovation, she’s more interested in home improvements than ever, dedicated to bringing you fresh and accurate content to help you update your living spaces.

Learn More

The ‘DuPont’ sofa from Andersen & Stauffer is an exact reproduction of one made in Philadelphia in the third quarter of the 18th century.

As you shop for that elusive sofa or settee for your early rooms, keep in mind that seating was a luxury only the well off could afford in our colonial days. The humblest and most common place to sit was a wooden bench or occasionally on a chest. In the absence of any other furniture, either might double as a place to sleep.

The bench, of course, has a history lost in time. As a furniture form, benches are distinct from chairs, which from medieval times were reserved for those of high status. It is also a forerunner of three more types of seating: the settle, the settee, and that modern essential the sofa.

Early versions of the bench range from crude seating slapped together from a plank of wood with side supports to variations that included squared or splayed supports, or solid ends with ogee-shaped profiles. Fancier benches had individual legs that were turned, chamfered, or square. The apex of early bench styling is probably the Windsor bench, skillfully made by a cabinetmaker with stick-and-socket joinery, or the spare yet meticulously crafted benches of the early 19th-century Shakers.


The settle is a more evolved and comfortable version of the bench. In use for over a millennium, a settle is a wooden bench with additions: backs, wings, side arms, even hoods-all important for added warmth in cold climates. There were settles with arms and a low back; settles with high backs and enclosing wings rather than arms; and settles where the high back converts to a table (or even a bed) when pulled down. High-backed settles in the late 1700s and early 1800s often had a lift-up seat over a storage box, occasionally even drawers. Both the back and sides of a settle are typically paneledor decorated in a style that depended on the origins and taste of the maker.

Fancier versions were supplemented with leather upholstery tacked on with nails, or came with slanted backrests. Owning a settle was a status symbol in early America, but late in the 18th century, the more prosperous classes began relaxing on a type called a settee.

Like the settle, a settee usually has a back and arms. Unlike the settle, it is often upholstered or padded on the seat, back, and arms. Some furniture historians argue that the settee is a double version of a chair; high-style settees certainly follow the same formal styling on arms and legs as fashionable chairs of the day. Other settees lean more in the direction of benches, especially those in the Windsor style popular in the second half of the 1700s and early 1800s.

A scroll-ended Empire sofa from the 1840s is supported by ornate claw feet.

Gridley + Graves

What defines a settee is its sense of lightness. While some are upholstered, a true settee has uncovered, fairly high legs, open sides, and slender arms.

The sofa took comfort to a new level through its emphasis on upholstery. Where the structure of a settee is usually quite visible, early sofas depended on hidden forms like front aprons and cabriole or serpentine backs to support upholstered seating. Many are graceful, without the high backs associated with either the settee or the settle. And where settees often had partially open or spindled backs, most 18th-century sofas offered the luxurious touch of a closed backrest.

High-style sofas followed the details of the day. A Federal-style sofa, for example, might be trimmed with woodwork featuring reeds or swags, while a scroll-ended Empire sofa borrowed the bolsters familiar from the daybed.

Early American designs declined in the mid-19th century as the upholstered sofa became an essential piece. We have the Colonial Revival of the late 19th and early 20th centuries to thank for bringing back the best examples of early seating, many still in production today.

A Grecian-style daybed from about 1825, attributed to master cabinetmaker Duncan Phyfe

The Daybed

This form undoubtedly dates to Roman times or even earlier. The Romans did everything in bed, from eating and socializing to running provinces and empires. The daybed is also the ancestor of the much later couch and the chaise longue (long chair). ¢ In 18th- and 19th-century America, this was a true bed, usually single, with a headboard and footboard of the same height. Intended to be placed lengthwise against a wall, the neoclassical daybed was more highly ornamented on the exposed side; bolsters served as armrests at either end. Useful for seating during waking hours, the daybed easily converts to a sleeping space for a nap or at night.

Despite its humble origins as a seat for four or more, this antique Shaker bench has a sculptural grace in this curated interior.

In Terms of Seating
bench A usually backless, elongated form of hard seating, often simply built of wood.
couch From the French word couche, it’s a place to lie down; the word is often used interchangeably with sofa today.
daybed A single bed with a headboard and footboard of the same height, which may be used for daytime seating withthe addition of pillows or bolsters.
divan A low sofa without arms. Theterm originates in the Mideast, where long, low benches without arms or back were built in or placed against a wall.
settee A small sofa with uncovered, fairly high legs, open sides, and slender arms.
settle A wood bench with a highback and arms, popularized in the1600s and early 1700s, and revivedduring the Arts & Crafts era.
sofa An upholstered seat for two or more people, with a fixed back and arms.

Hancock & Moore’s ‘Drake’ bench is a low-backed upholstered bench with fluted, tapered legs that suggest the Federal style.

Selected sources

¢ American Heritage Shop
¢ Andersen & Stauffer
¢ Circa Home Living
¢ Cobblestone Cottage/Lt. Moses Willard
¢ D.R. Dimes
¢ Fable Porch by March Legend
¢ Great Windsor Chairs
¢ Hancock & Moore
¢ Lawrence Crouse Workshop
¢ Martin’s Chair
¢ Shaker Workshops
¢ Stickley
¢ Warren Chair Works
¢ Windsors by BillWallick

Editorial Contributors
avatar for Old House Journal

Old House Journal

Founded in 1973, Old House Journal is the original authority when it comes to old-house restoration, traditional house styles, period kitchens, bath & kitchen restoration, DIY projects, gardens & landscaping, and more-- from Colonial and Victorian through Arts & Crafts and Mid-century Modern homes.

Learn More